Home › How we check

How we check

This page explains exactly how a product ends up on a list, and where the method can be wrong.

1. The data

We use USDA FoodData Central, Branded Foods. Each record has the ingredient text printed on the pack, a serving size, and nutrient values per 100 g. Where the serving size is given in grams, we calculate per-serving values from the per-100 g values. If it is not given in grams, the value shows “n/a”.

Which products are included: we pulled every USDA record whose text matches “peanut butter” (6,525 records) and every record for potato chips (5,166). We kept the ones filed as spreads and nut butters (peanut butter) or as chips and snacks (potato chips, which includes sweet potato chips), dropped products that only contain the words, such as candy, cookies, cereal, bars and powders, and kept one entry for each product line, using the newest record. That leaves 1,001 peanut butter and 4,103 potato chip products.

2. The rule for each list

Peanut butter without palm oil. A product passes if its ingredient text contains none of: palm oil, palm fruit oil, palm kernel oil, palm olein, palm stearin, palm shortening, or hydrogenated palm oil.

Potato chips without seed oils. “Seed oil” has no single agreed definition, so we use a literal list of names. A product passes if its ingredient text contains none of: soybean, canola, rapeseed, sunflower, safflower, cottonseed, corn oil, grapeseed, rice bran oil, “vegetable oil” or “vegetable shortening”. We make no claim that these oils are good or bad.

3. Your own filter

On each list you can type extra words to leave out, such as sugar or soy. We then hide every product whose ingredient text contains that word.

Limits you should know

  • Each product shows the date of its USDA record. Many records are several years old and a recipe may have changed since.
  • A label that says only “vegetable oil” does not name the oil, so the text cannot tell us which oil it is.
  • Matching is on text. A different spelling or a typo in the record can hide or show a product wrongly.
  • The database covers products sold in the United States and is not complete.
  • We do not rank products by quality, taste or health.